Litter Mat vs. Litter Catcher Mat: Which Keeps Floors Cleaner?
By Beast & Buckle | Published: 2026-11-04
Category: Comparaisons
Compare the Arm & Hammer Paws Litter Mat and the Petmate Paws Large Litter Catcher Mat on size, material, and cleaning to decide which litter tracking solution fits your cat and floor space.
Quick Answer
Choose the Arm & Hammer Paws Litter Mat if you want a low-cost, easy-to-shake mat for a standard litter box setup. Choose the Petmate Paws Large Litter Catcher Mat if you have a larger space or a messy cat and want a bigger, softer surface to trap more litter.
Size and placement decide most of the result
The Petmate mat measures 35 by 23.5 inches, giving you a large landing zone that suits a big litter box or a cat that kicks litter far. The Arm & Hammer mat’s exact dimensions are not listed in the catalog, so if floor coverage is your top priority, the Petmate’s stated size is the safer bet. For tight bathrooms or closets, the Arm & Hammer’s smaller footprint may fit more easily—but check the product options for available sizes before you buy.
Material affects comfort and cleaning
The Arm & Hammer mat uses durable rubber that stays in place and is easy to clean: shake it over a trash can, then hand wash with cold water and air dry. The Petmate mat uses a soft, rubberized material that is gentle on paws and a webbed design that locks litter inside the mat. Softer material may feel nicer underfoot, but the Arm & Hammer’s simpler rubber surface may be quicker to rinse and dry. Neither mat is machine washable according to the supplied facts, so plan on hand cleaning either way.
Price and value trade-off
At $8.99 (compared with a $17.99 list price), the Arm & Hammer mat is the budget-friendly pick. The Petmate mat is $17.50 (compared with $34.99), so you pay more for the larger size and soft rubberized feel. If you only need light scatter control around a single box, the Arm & Hammer covers the job for less. If litter tracking is a daily battle, the Petmate’s larger surface may save you more cleanup time in the long run.
Key Trade-Offs
- Size vs. floor space: The Petmate mat gives you a stated 35 by 23.5 inches of coverage; the Arm & Hammer mat’s dimensions are not listed, so measure your available floor area and compare with the product options before deciding. If you have a large litter area, the Petmate is the clearer choice; for tight spots, check the Arm & Hammer’s available sizes.
- Softness vs. simple cleaning: The Petmate’s soft rubberized material is gentle on paws but may need more careful hand washing; the Arm & Hammer’s durable rubber is easy to shake out and hand wash with cold water. Pick based on whether paw comfort or quick cleanup matters more to you.
- Upfront cost vs. long-term mess: The Arm & Hammer mat costs $8.99 versus $17.50 for the Petmate. The Petmate’s larger surface may catch more litter from messy cats, potentially reducing daily sweeping. If litter scatter is severe, the higher-priced Petmate may pay off in less cleaning time.
Product Facts
- Arm & Hammer Paws Litter Mat: Durable rubber material with a unique webbing pattern to capture litter scatter. The rubber grip helps the mat stay put, and the webbing gives litter a place to fall instead of rolling onto the floor.
Arm & Hammer Paws Litter Mat - Petmate Paws Large Litter Catcher Mat: Measures 35 by 23.5 inches and is made from a soft, rubberized material with a webbed design. The large size covers more floor around the box, and the soft material is comfortable for paws while trapping litter.
Petmate Paws Large Litter Catcher Mat
Which Mat Fits Your Home?
Best for
- Budget-conscious owners who want a simple, easy-to-clean mat for a standard litter box.
- Small spaces where a compact mat is easier to place.
Not for
- Cats that kick litter far or homes with large litter areas—choose the Petmate for more coverage.
- Owners who prefer a softer surface under their cat’s paws.
