The cap clicked right onto my half-gallon gravity waterer, no wobble at all. I was worried replacement lids wouldn't seal as well as the original, but this one holds the water level steady overnight.
Hazel★★★★★
Ordered this as a spare for our 1/2 gallon gravity waterer and it screwed right on with no leaks. The cap seals tight against the bottle threads, so no more slow drips onto the floor.
Lily★★★★★
Wasn't sure this cap would fit since the listing warns the styles vary by size, but it lines right up with the 1/2 gallon bottle I've got. No leaking at the seal so far, which is more than I can say for the cracked original.